Wednesday, May 19, 2010

Texas SBOE Member, Barbara Cargill, Sets the Record Straight on Textbook Changes

The following information was sent to me in an email.  I attempted to link to the original source ( several times, but received an error page.  In any case, since the Texas State Board of Education's changes to the TEKS will have such an immense effect on textbooks across the entire nation, this information affects virtually everyone with kids in school.  I applaud the changes I see here.

Also see this Fox New Video Texas Textbook Wars

Texas SBOE Member, Barbara Cargill, Sets the Record Straight on Textbook Changes
By Barbara Cargill, Chair, Committee on Instruction

It is after much hard work, and input from many, that I want to take this opportunity to provide every Texan with a ”Fact Sheet” to help clear up much of the misinformation from the media about the K-Grade 12 social studies standards.  Many of us on the State Board of Education (SBOE) continue to work diligently for rigorous history standards that teach our children about their rich heritage and emphasize our country’s founding principles. 

We want students to learn more about the Founding Fathers and patriot heroes of both our state and nation.

Important leaders who were neglected previously have been added to the standards.  These include John Quincy Adams, John Hancock and John Wise.

And we have placed stronger emphasis on key historical documents such as the Declaration of Independence and Constitution. Students will learn the liberties and responsibilities guaranteed by each amendment in the Bill of Rights.

Here are examples of some of the outstanding standards that have passed so far:
American History:

  • The student understands the concept of American exceptionalism.
  • Describe how American values are different and unique from those of other nations;
  • Describe U. S. citizens as people from numerous places throughout the world, who hold a common bond in standing for certain self-evident truths.
  • Discuss the meaning and historical significance of the mottos “E Pluribus Unum” and “In God We Trust.”
U.S. Government:

Analyze selected issues raised by judicial activism and judicial restraint.

Grades 1-3: (with the word “equality” added in Grades 2-3)
  • Identify characteristics of good citizenship including truthfulness, respect for others and oneself, responsibility in daily life, and participation in government by educating oneself about the issues, holding public officials to their word, and voting.
Grade 6:
  • Understand the importance of morality and ethics in maintaining a functional free enterprise system.
Grade 8:
  • Describe how religion and virtue contributed to the growth of representative government in the American colonies.
Over the last few months, the SBOE has heard testimony from people representing:
  • League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC)
  • Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund (MALDEF)
  • Texas Families of Incarcerated Youth
  • Sikh Coalition
  • U.T. Austin Department of History
  • Carrizo-Comecrudo Tribe of Texas
  • Hindu-American Foundation
  • Coalition for Educational Reform
  • Texas Holocaust & Genocide Commission, and
  • many other individuals
We have been asked to include more minorities, more liberal groups, less about our Judeo-Christian heritage, less about limited government, more about race and gender, and less about free markets and gun rights.

The final vote is on May 21stThe SBOE needs help from patriots across the state to ensure that the revisions we have made to the standards are upheld.

On Wednesday, May 19th we will have a full day of public testimony.  People from many of the same organizations listed above will be back to speak to the SBOE.

Please use this opportunity to come and address the Board yourself!

Signing up to testify for the May 19th State Board meeting begins on Friday, May 14th.

Please call the Texas Education Agency early at 512-463-9581.  If coming to Austin is not an option, let your voice be heard by e-mailing

The proposed social studies standards are posted at Charts that list the historical figures in the social studies standards are posted on that same page for verification of information.

Please take a look at the standards, and come to conclusions for yourself.

Thank you for your encouraging messages and for your support about this important issue.   The Fact Sheet is pasted below for your convenience.


State Board of Education Social Studies TEKS Fact Sheet

A.  FALSE ALLEGATION: The State Board of Education is not listening to educators and experts and as such the SBOE should send the social studies standards back to the original review committees.

FACT:  The Social Studies TEKS review committees and some history experts made some revisions that were unsupportable, and the State Board of Education had to direct changes or vote to return to the original content.

Christmas, Neil Armstrong, Thomas Edison, Albert Einstein, religious heritage language, Independence Day, Veterans Day and Christopher Columbus were either removed completely or partially from several grade levels by the review committees. The State Board of Education members have assured concerned members of the public that these historical figures and important concepts were placed back in the standards where they had been taught for the previous 10 years.

This action was based on the urging and feedback from numerous educators, experts and concerned members of the public. One “historian” even suggested Alexander Graham Bell and the Texas Rangers should be removed from Texas social studies standards. This recommendation was not adopted.

B. FALSE ALLEGATION: The State Board of Education is making decisions on its own and not listening to educators.

FACT:  Numerous educators urged the State Board of Education to teach students accurately about the country’s religious heritage and American Exceptionalism.
The State Board of Education voted to include requirements that students study about America ’s religious heritage and American Exceptionalism.

C. FALSE ALLEGATION: The State Board of Education is deleting minority figures from the social studies curriculum.

FACT: The proposed Social Studies TEKS include more minority representation than ever before.

Among the many individuals who have been added to the standards are:

1.    Crispus Attucks
2.    Jose Bernardo Guillermo de Lara
3.    Alvar Nunez Cabeza de Vaca
4.    Wentworth Cheswell
5.    Francisco Coronado
6.    Bernardo de Galvez
7.    Juan de Onate
8.    Adina de Zavala
9.    Enrique Esparza
10.  W.E.B. DuBois
11.   Carmen Lomas Garza
12.   Henry B. Gonzalez
13.   Raul A. Gonzalez
14.   Maria Mitchell
15.   Ellen Ochoa
16.   Jose Antonio Navaro
17.   Irma Rangel
18.   Juan Seguin
19.   Erasmo Seguin
20.   Phillis Wheatley
21.   Lulu Belle White
22.   Diane Gonzales Bertrand
23.   Simon Bolivar
24.   Bessie Coleman
25.   Tomie de Paola
26.   Marcus Garvey
27.   Lydia Mendoza
28.   Kadir Nelson
29.   Danny Olivas
30.   Raymond Telles and
31.   Amado Pena Jr.
D. FALSE ALLEGATION:  The State Board of Education is eliminating Cesar Chavez and Thurgood Marshall from the standards.

FACT:  The State Board of Education members have not made any amendments to delete Cesar Chavez or Thurgood Marshall. The SBOE actually increased the emphasis placed on these historically significant individuals.

Both Cesar Chavez and Thurgood Marshall have been made required elements of the curriculum framework. Students will study the legacy of these historically significant men in both the elementary grades and in high school, as Cesar Chavez has been added to Grade 5 American history and Thurgood Marshall has been added to the Grade 2 standards. Both already are taught in U.S. History Since 1877.

E. FALSE ALLEGATION:  The State Board of Education has included conservative groups in the Social Studies TEKS without listing any liberal organizations.

FACT:  The curriculum standards include historically significant individuals and groups from a wide array of ethnic, cultural, racial and religious backgrounds.

For example, the League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC) is required study at two different grade levels. The National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) also is required, as is separate study of founders W.E.B. DuBois and Ida B. Wells at various grade levels. Other notable leaders such as Anne Richards, Hillary Clinton, Barbara Jordan also are included.

Students are required to study various social and political advocacy positions, including organizations that promoted civil rights for African Americans, Chicanos and American Indians. Individuals who promoted civil rights, labor rights and women’s rights also are included, such as:
  • Upton Sinclair
  • Susan B. Anthony
  • Elizabeth Cady Stanton
  • Ida B. Wells
  • W.E.B.DuBois
  • Clarence Darrow
  • Martin Luther King Jr.
  • Cesar Chavez
  • Thurgood Marshall
  • Hector P. Garcia
  • Frances Willard
  • Jane Addams and
  • Dolores Huerta
The proposed history standards include diverse individuals and groups for study at each grade level.

F. FALSE ALLEGATION:  The State Board of Education is excluding Hispanic and African American Medal of Honor recipients.

FACT:  The State Board of Education expects students to know the significant contributions and heroic actions of Medal of Honor recipients from all backgrounds.

The SBOE added Medal of Honor recipients William Carney and Philip Bazaar to Grade 8 American history, and added Medal of Honor recipients Vernon J. Baker and Roy Benavides to the high school U.S. History course. The social studies curriculum standards specifically require that students study male and female Medal of Honor recipients of various racial backgrounds.

G. FALSE ALLEGATION:  The State Board of Education has eliminated Tejanos who fought at the Alamo.

FACT:  The Social Studies TEKS include Tejano leaders who fought at the Alamo.

In Grade 4 Texas history, Tejanos Juan Seguin , Placido Benavides and Francisco Ruiz are required to be studied as important participants in the Texas Revolution. Lorenzo de Zavala and Jose Antonio Navarro, Tejano leaders who died at the Alamo, also are required figures in Grade 4.

In Grade 7 Texas history, students again study the significant roles played by Tejano leaders Lorenzo de Zavala and Juan Seguin as they review the events of the Texas Revolution, the siege of the Alamo and the Battle of San Jacinto.

H. FALSE ALLEGATION:  The State Board of Education has removed capitalism from the standards and substituted it with “free enterprise system.”

FACT:  In Texas , students are required to study economics with an emphasis on the free-enterprise system and its benefits. “Free enterprise system” is the terminology used in the TEKS since 1998 to describe the U.S. economic system.

The State Board of Education has voted to retain this term in the social studies standards. At each grade level starting in Grade 2, however, information has been added that states:

“Students identify the role of the U.S. free enterprise system within the parameters of this course and understand that this system may also be referred to as capitalism or the free market system.”

The SBOE will be retaining the term “free enterprise system” that aligns with state requirements.

I. FALSE ALLEGATION:  Thomas Jefferson has been removed or downplayed in the Social Studies curriculum framework.

FACT:  Only George Washington is emphasized more heavily than Thomas Jefferson in the social studies standards.

Thomas Jefferson is taught in Grade 5 American history, in Grade 8 American history and in U.S. Government. These are the same grades where Jefferson and his important legacy have always been taught, and the State Board of Education has not changed this emphasis.

As the author of the Declaration of Independence , and as a strong proponent of limited government and states’ rights, Thomas Jefferson is the type of Founding Father and patriot hero about whom students should learn more, not less.

J. FALSE ALLEGATION:  The State Board of Education has decided we no longer live in a democracy.

FACT:  The United States is a constitutional republic, not a democracy.

The Pledge of Allegiance correctly identifies our form of government as a republic, and the State Board of Education members expect students to recite that pledge and understand its meaning. This reference to constitutional republic refers to the form of government our Founding Fathers instituted.

K. FALSE ALLEGATION:  The State Board of Education doesn’t believe students should learn about separation of church and state or First Amendment rights.

FACT:  Students in elementary grades, middle school and high school will learn about the important freedoms guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution, as the Bill of Rights is outlined in Grade 5, Grade 8 and again in U.S. Government.

First Amendment rights are among the most fundamental we share in this country. Each of these freedoms should be studied, including the freedom of religion. Constitutional protection of religion was provided by banning the Federal Government, specifically Congress from establishing a national religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.

A majority of the State Board of Education members voted against a new amendment to the TEKS because its wording downplayed the “free exercise” clause. The Founding Fathers actually encouraged religion, as can be seen in the emphasis given religion in the Northwest Ordinance which passed the same year the Constitutional Convention convened to draft the U.S. Constitution.

Finally, and so importantly, please take time to review the proposed Social Studies TEKS, posted at

Charts that list the historical figures in the Social Studies TEKS also are posted on that same page for verification of information.



  2. I read the plot overview via your link, and didn't think much of the book. SURELY, advance placement teachers can find better literature than that book. Just my opinion.